.png)
What is the Best Therapy For Anxiety?
- Jul 14
- 6 min read
CBT, ACT, EMDR, and More: Which Anxiety Therapy Is Right for You?
You're probably not surprised to hear that the short answer to "what is the best therapy for anxiety" is, "it depends".
Anxiety is a broad category of feeling and experience and the best approach is going to depend on your specific struggles and needs.
Someone who experiences panic attacks may need a different treatment focus than someone with obsessive-compulsive disorder, social anxiety, health anxiety, trauma-related anxiety, or chronic stress.
The slightly longer answer to the question is that Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is the most evidenced based treatment for anxiety. It's important to note, however, that CBT can refer both to an umbrella category of therapies that focus on the interaction between thoughts, feelings, and behaviors and also a specific, structured approach to therapy based on thought restructuring and behavioral activation. CBT as an umbrella category includes specific approaches and treatments such as exposure, exposure and response prevention (ERP), Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT), Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), and others.
Let's explore some of the therapy approaches most likely to be used to treat anxiety. I will discuss in what situations they are most helpful and some of the drawbacks.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (as a standalone treatment)
CBT is one of the most widely studied treatments and it's structured approach makes it appealing to both study and teach. It is based on the idea that our thoughts, emotions, and behaviors influence one another.
In CBT, you may learn to identify unhelpful thinking patterns, examine whether your interpretations are accurate or useful, challenge unhelpful thoughts, and change behaviors that reinforce anxiety.
CBT may be particularly helpful for:
Generalized anxiety and chronic worry
Social anxiety
Health anxiety
Phobias
Panic attacks and panic disorder
Anxiety connected to worst case scenario or catastrophic thinking
People who appreciate a structured and practical approach
Possible drawbacks:
CBT can become too focused on correcting thoughts if it is practiced rigidly. Some people find that challenging thinking patterns does not address the emotions and somatic symptoms they experience with anxiety. Also, a person can also turn cognitive restructuring into another form of reassurance, repeatedly trying to prove that nothing bad will happen.
Exposure Therapy
Exposure therapy helps people intentionally and gradually approach feared situations, sensations, memories, thoughts, or uncertainties rather than continuing to avoid them.
Avoidance tends to provide immediate relief, which teaches the brain that avoidance protected you from danger. Over time, this can make the feared situation seem even more threatening. Exposure gives your brain opportunities to learn that anxiety can be experienced without automatically escaping, seeking reassurance, or performing another safety behavior.
Exposure therapy may be particularly helpful for:
Panic attacks and fear of bodily sensations
Phobias
Social anxiety
Health anxiety
Agoraphobia
OCD
Trauma-related avoidance
Anxiety that has caused your life to become increasingly restricted
Possible drawbacks:
Exposure can feel intimidating, particularly when it is poorly explained or introduced too quickly. It should be collaborative, purposeful, and connected to a clear understanding of the anxiety cycle.
Exposure and Response Prevention
Exposure and Response Prevention, or ERP, is a specific form of exposure therapy most closely associated with treating obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). The exposure portion involves approaching a trigger, intrusive thought, uncertainty, or feared possibility. Response prevention means resisting the compulsion or ritual that would normally follow.
ERP may be particularly helpful for:
Obsessive-compulsive disorder or related behaviors
Intrusive thoughts
Anxiety involving repetitive reassurance or mental rituals
Possible drawbacks:
ERP can feel difficult, especially early in treatment. Treatment of OCD with ERP is generally done by therapists with specialized training.
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, or ACT, focuses less on changing the content of thoughts and more on changing how you respond to them. ACT also promotes the development of psychological flexibility and approaching, rather than avoiding, discomfort.
One important ACT skill is cognitive defusion. Defusion helps you see thoughts as mental events rather than unquestionable facts, urgent instructions, or problems that must immediately be solved.
ACT may be particularly helpful for:
Chronic worry and overthinking
Perfectionism
Anxiety that has become a struggle against anxiety itself
People who understand that their worries may be exaggerated but still feel controlled by them
People whose lives have become organized around avoiding discomfort
Possible drawbacks:
ACT is less skill based compared to the therapies mention thus far. While there are skills to be learned, ACT promotes a shift in the way in which you interact with difficulties and this can take time to learn.
Mindfulness-Based Therapy & Somatic Therapies
Mindfulness involves intentionally paying attention to the present moment without judgement or interpretation. Mindfulness-based treatments may include Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction, Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy, or mindfulness skills incorporated into modalities. Somatic therapies prioritize the mind-body connection and uses focus on the body and somatic sensations in its approach. Somatic approaches can include incorporating breathwork and body-based exercises into therapy, an approach based on Polyvagal theory with accompanying exercises, and Somatic Experiencing (SE) as primary treatment approach to trauma.
Mindfulness-based therapy may be particularly helpful for:
General stress and anxiety
Rumination and overthinking
Difficulty tolerating emotions
Anxiety accompanied by physical tension
People who feel disconnected from the present because they are constantly anticipating the future
A preference for body based treatments
Possible drawbacks:
Mindfulness is not always sufficient as a stand-alone treatment for an anxiety disorder. Someone with panic disorder, OCD, or a phobia may learn to observe their anxiety but still need targeted exposure work. For many with more significant anxiety symptoms it is a helpful adjunct treatment rather than the only treatment.
Psychodynamic Therapy
Psychodynamic therapy explores how past experiences, emotional conflicts, defenses, attachment patterns, and relationship dynamics may contribute to current anxiety.
Treatment may examine why certain situations feel especially threatening, how a person protects themselves from uncomfortable emotions, and how recurring interpersonal patterns appear both inside and outside therapy.
Psychodynamic therapy may be particularly helpful for:
Anxiety connected to relationships or attachment
Repeating emotional or interpersonal patterns
Anxiety accompanied by shame, identity concerns, or internal conflict
People who want to understand the deeper origins and meaning of their reactions
Possible drawbacks:
Psychodynamic therapy may be less direct than CBT or exposure-based treatment. Insight into why anxiety developed does not always change the behaviors that currently maintain it. For panic, OCD, phobias, and other fear-based conditions, a treatment that does not address avoidance or compulsions may leave an important part of the problem untouched.
Trauma-focused Therapies for Anxiety
Sometimes the root of anxiety is trauma or distressing experiences. When this is the case, the trauma will ultimately need to be addressed. Some common trauma-focused therapies include:
Accelerated Resolution Therapy (ART): A trauma-focused therapy that uses eye movements, guided imagery, memory reconsolidation techniques, and imagery rescripting.
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR): A trauma-focused therapy that helps people process distressing memories and the beliefs, emotions, and physical reactions connected to them. During EMDR, the person briefly focuses on aspects of a distressing memory while engaging in bilateral stimulation, often through guided eye movements, tapping, or alternating sounds.
Cognitive Processing Therapy: A structured, trauma-focused therapy that helps people identify and challenge unhelpful beliefs that stem from the traumatic experience.
So Which Therapy Is Actually Best for Anxiety?
For many anxiety disorders, a blend of the above approaches that addresses individual presentations and needs is best. The nuances of your anxiety matter and an effective therapist will work to understand the contributing and sustaining factors of your anxiety and will develop a plan unique to you. For most, effective anxiety treatment will address the thoughts and beliefs that underscore the anxiety as well as the behaviors that sustain it while weaving in a variety of other approaches to meet your individual needs.
A useful way to think about the options is:
CBT helps you understand and change patterns of thinking and behavior.
Exposure therapy helps you approach what anxiety has taught you to avoid.
ERP is especially important when anxiety involves obsessions and compulsions.
ACT helps you stop organizing your life around the goal of never feeling anxious.
Mindfulness-based therapy helps you notice thoughts and sensations without automatically reacting to them.
EMDR and ART may be particularly relevant when anxiety is strongly connected to trauma or distressing memories.
Psychodynamic therapies explore meaning, identity, relationships, and the larger story surrounding anxiety.
These approaches do not have to compete with one another. A therapist may use CBT to explain the anxiety cycle, ACT to build willingness to experience discomfort, mindfulness to strengthen present-moment awareness, and exposure to create new learning through experience. There are of course many other therapeutic approaches your therapist may include to address all of the nuances of you and your anxiety but the approaches addressed in this post are the primary, evidenced based strategies for treating anxiety.
Struggling with Anxiety?
Katie Bernard, LCSW is a Sarasota | Lakewood Ranch, Florida therapist providing online therapy to adults across Florida and in-person in Sarasota | Lakewood Ranch | Bradenton
.png)
.png)